flies&bikes

science - cycling - technology

Tour de France Stage 15 “Chaingate” – was Contador right…or wrong?

During Stage 15 of the 2010 Tour de France, Alberto Contador (Astana) took yellow after Andy Schleck (Saxo Bank) suffered an unshipped chain near the top of the major climb of Port de Balès.  Some people reckon this was an “unsporting” thing for Contador to have done, and indeed some quite vituperative exchanges have been going on in cycling forums all across the interweb.
Personally, I think you need to bear in mind this was nearing the top of a climb, that the riders will have been really on the rivet, with all the attendant hullaballoo of the motorcade, helicopters and suchlike associated with the Tour de France.  Add into the mix the fact that all the likely podium contenders were there, it seems that Contador did the right thing, and specifically:

  • he had no way of knowing how significant the mechanical issue was (assuming he realised there was a mechanical problem)
  • he had no way of knowing how long it would take Schleck to deal with the issue
  • what would have happened had he waited, and the others had carried on?

I think the critics of Contador’s actions need to remember this is race, not a club run…  Here’s a video of the event (YouTube)

And finally – at last a commentator who takes a rational view of the situation as it unfolds: Opinion: It’s wrong to vilify Contador by Neal Rogers (Velonews.com).  Neal points out pretty much what I do above, and also adds:

But, like most things in life, this situation not that simple — and most people will make their judgments based upon how they already felt about either Contador or Schleck. We saw that during last year’s race, when diehard Lance Armstrong fans vilified Contador, ignoring the facts that Armstrong made his comeback into Contador’s team, that Armstrong did what he could to turn the team against Contador, and that the Spaniard did what he needed to do to assert himself as the strongest rider in last year’s Tour.

You could certainly discern the anti-Contador bias in comments left at the VeloNews site yesterday, and I’d concur with Neal as to the motivation.  Let’s all see how this most interesting Tour unfolds en route to Paris.

This entry was posted in Cycling and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

 

Music taste map

 

Summer Tour 2012

In order to view this object you need Flash Player 9+ support!

Get Adobe Flash player
Joomla! Slideshow
 

Wonderful Life

Latest at the Team Grumpy blog

Team Grumpy

Twitter

GrumpyBob
geneticist, cyclist, coffee-lover, blogger
U.K.
“@davecameroon: On WebCameroon Direct: "Hello, my name is Michael Gove!" /ht AAV pic.twitter.com/u3V2VXsWnU” #GoveMustGo

3 days ago via Twitter for Mac

@Cycling_Chef @brooksengland B17 a bit heavy for racing, but for all day comfort, it can’t be beaten. Mrs Grumpy uses B17 Standard.

6 days ago via Tweetbot for iOS in reply to Cycling_Chef

@Cycling_Chef @brooksengland I still tour on a Brooks B17 Narrow that I have had for 42 years!

6 days ago via Tweetbot for iOS in reply to Cycling_Chef

"Health tourism is a huge problem", say Ministers. In reality, it costs the NHS 0.15% of NHS spending. fullfact.org/factchecks/cos… HT @ClareRCGP

Retweeted 6 days ago via Twitter for Mac • 38 retweets

I now have something in common with Wiggins: I've been beaten in a time trial by Dowsett. I cannot blame a puncture/bike change, however.

6 days ago via Twitter for Mac

 
Team Grumpy Blog
Find me on Mendeley
Wonderful Life
Find me at Academia.edu
Follow Me
My Library